[Pellet-users] Possible bugs detected in Pellet 1.4RC2

[Evren Sirin]

On 3/6/07 12:10 PM, Federico Peinado wrote:
> Hi everybody,
>
> It is my first message in the list, but me and my group have been using
> Pellet (nice tool!) so much time ago.
>   
Yes, we have come across your project (KIIDS) at some point and it 
became one of our favorite applications using Pellet!
> We have two problems.
>
> ---
> The first one is about integration of Pellet1.4RC2 with Jena 2.5.2. It
> is strange because we don´t have this problem with Jena 2.5.1 or Jena
> 2.5.0. The error looks like this:
>
> testGetAnnotationPropertyIndividuals(es.ucm.disia.dlmodel.test.JenaModelTest)java.lang.NoClassDefFoundError: 
[snip]
>
> Is not com/hp/hpl/jena/rdql/QueryResults a Jena deprecated package?
> Strange... where is the call to that package in Pellet? I am not able to
> find it in the source code :(
>
> Is anybody working with Pellet 1.4RC2 + Jena 2.5.2 without problems?
>   
Yes, this is a known issue. Jena 2.5.2 removed some of the deprecated 
API from 2.5.1 and corresponding (deprecated) functions in Pellet cause 
this problem. Pellet SVN has been updated since then and works fine with 
Jena 2.5.2.
> ---
> The second problem is about some possible bugs in Pellet 1.4RC2.
>
> It SEEMS that reasoning with user-defined datatypes with decimals and
> open/closed intervals is not working propertly. Concretely we have found
> strange behaviour in:
>
>      * [number without decimals, number with decimals)
>      * (number without decimals, number with decimals]
>
> it means:
>
>      * MinInclusive<no decimals> MaxExclusive<decimals>
>      * MinExclusive<no decimals> MaxInclusive<decimals>
>
> We are working in a ontology of Emotions and we tested these intervals:
>            o Anger: [7,10]
>            o Displeasures: [7,7.5)
>            o Annoyance: [7.5,8)
>            o Sulking: [8,8.5)
>            o Indignation: [8.5,9)
>            o Fury: [9,10]
>
> Annoyance, Indignation and Fury are ok (under Anger), but Displeasure
> and Sulking went under Annoyance, Indignation and Fury (?) instead of
> Anger.
>
> The same example but without decimals:
>            o Anger: [5,10]
>            o Displeasures: [5,6)
>            o Annoyance: [6,7)
>            o Sulking: [7,8)
>            o Indignation: [8,9)
>            o Fury: [9,10]
>
> and everything works propertly (all of them under Anger)
>
> Changing open intervals for closed intervals and viceversa:
>            o Anger: [7,10]
>            o Displeasures: [7,7.5]
>            o Annoyance: (7.5,8]
>            o Sulking: (8,8.5]
>            o Indignation: (8.5,9]
>            o Fury: (9,10]
>
> everything ok but Sulking that is under Annoyance, Indignation and Fury
> (?). It seems that [no decimals, decimals) is not working propertly.
>
> Changing Sulking like this:
>              o annoyance: (7,7.5)
>            o Sulking: [8,8.5]
>
> and everything is ok again. It seems that (no decimals, decimals] does
> not work also.
>
> Last test, just changing Fury:
>            o Fury: (9,9.5]
>
> and Fury went to the bad place, under the other 4 concepts...
> again it seems that (no decimlas, decimals] is not working as we expected.
>
> Any ideas? Are these bugs (in the case they are bugs) fixed in the SVN
> version?
>   
This looks like a bug and I don't think any of the changes after RC2 
would fix this. It might be just a problem with xsd:decimal (and might 
work with xsd:float). Could you please provide a link to the ontology so 
I can test it? Personal e-mail would be fine.

Thanks,
Evren
> Thanks in advance!
> - Federico Peinado
>    http://federicopeinado.com
>
>
>
>
> _______________________________________________
> Pellet-users mailing list
> Pellet-users at lists.owldl.com
> http://lists.owldl.com/mailman/listinfo/pellet-users
> _______________________________________________
>
> Sponsored by Clark & Parsia, LLC http://clarkparsia.com/
>