[Pellet-users] Possible bugs detected in Pellet 1.4RC2

[Federico Peinado]

Hi everybody,

It is my first message in the list, but me and my group have been using
Pellet (nice tool!) so much time ago.

We have two problems.

---
The first one is about integration of Pellet1.4RC2 with Jena 2.5.2. It
is strange because we don´t have this problem with Jena 2.5.1 or Jena
2.5.0. The error looks like this:

testGetAnnotationPropertyIndividuals(es.ucm.disia.dlmodel.test.JenaModelTest)java.lang.NoClassDefFoundError: 



com/hp/hpl/jena/rdql/QueryResults
     at
org.mindswap.pellet.jena.PelletInfGraph.<init>(PelletInfGraph.java:158)
     at org.mindswap.pellet.jena.PelletReasoner.bind(PelletReasoner.java:84)
     at
com.hp.hpl.jena.ontology.impl.OntModelImpl.generateGraph(OntModelImpl.java:2729) 



     at
com.hp.hpl.jena.ontology.impl.OntModelImpl.<init>(OntModelImpl.java:143)
     at
com.hp.hpl.jena.ontology.impl.OntModelImpl.<init>(OntModelImpl.java:132)
     at
com.hp.hpl.jena.rdf.model.ModelFactory.createOntologyModel(ModelFactory.java:448) 



     at es.ucm.disia.dlmodel.JenaModel.init(JenaModel.java:205)
     at es.ucm.disia.dlmodel.JenaModel.<init>(JenaModel.java:61)
     at es.ucm.disia.dlmodel.test.JenaModelTest.setUp(JenaModelTest.java:28)
     at es.ucm.disia.dlmodel.test.JenaModelTest.main(JenaModelTest.java:394)

Is not com/hp/hpl/jena/rdql/QueryResults a Jena deprecated package?
Strange... where is the call to that package in Pellet? I am not able to
find it in the source code :(

Is anybody working with Pellet 1.4RC2 + Jena 2.5.2 without problems?

---
The second problem is about some possible bugs in Pellet 1.4RC2.

It SEEMS that reasoning with user-defined datatypes with decimals and
open/closed intervals is not working propertly. Concretely we have found
strange behaviour in:

     * [number without decimals, number with decimals)
     * (number without decimals, number with decimals]

it means:

     * MinInclusive<no decimals> MaxExclusive<decimals>
     * MinExclusive<no decimals> MaxInclusive<decimals>

We are working in a ontology of Emotions and we tested these intervals:
           o Anger: [7,10]
           o Displeasures: [7,7.5)
           o Annoyance: [7.5,8)
           o Sulking: [8,8.5)
           o Indignation: [8.5,9)
           o Fury: [9,10]

Annoyance, Indignation and Fury are ok (under Anger), but Displeasure
and Sulking went under Annoyance, Indignation and Fury (?) instead of
Anger.

The same example but without decimals:
           o Anger: [5,10]
           o Displeasures: [5,6)
           o Annoyance: [6,7)
           o Sulking: [7,8)
           o Indignation: [8,9)
           o Fury: [9,10]

and everything works propertly (all of them under Anger)

Changing open intervals for closed intervals and viceversa:
           o Anger: [7,10]
           o Displeasures: [7,7.5]
           o Annoyance: (7.5,8]
           o Sulking: (8,8.5]
           o Indignation: (8.5,9]
           o Fury: (9,10]

everything ok but Sulking that is under Annoyance, Indignation and Fury
(?). It seems that [no decimals, decimals) is not working propertly.

Changing Sulking like this:
             o annoyance: (7,7.5)
           o Sulking: [8,8.5]

and everything is ok again. It seems that (no decimals, decimals] does
not work also.

Last test, just changing Fury:
           o Fury: (9,9.5]

and Fury went to the bad place, under the other 4 concepts...
again it seems that (no decimlas, decimals] is not working as we expected.

Any ideas? Are these bugs (in the case they are bugs) fixed in the SVN
version?

Thanks in advance!
- Federico Peinado
   http://federicopeinado.com